理性分析，UPS6转降多哈着陆成功的可能性
多哈机场位于第一次火警发出100英里，而折返迪拜航程207英里，空管不需要其他飞机传话，能输入ILS截获，火势没有疯狂蔓延损坏机长氧气供应，成功着陆可能性多大，机长的决定又多少影响了飞机的命运。
估计也不太适合，毕竟下降率不足（就是转向也来不及，这不是空优战斗机，这是满载且着火的民航运输机，结构承受不了剧烈机动的变型压力的），多哈的五边区需要向南绕才能降吧？那样的话最後的降落会比在迪拜更危险吧？
为啥你们都只根据一个纪录片就进行讨论？调查报告里面已经讨论过了
Doha Diversion
The investigation examined the possible outcome of an alternative scenario of diverting to DOH at the first indication of the fire. From the point where the diversion to Doha was advised there were 100 track miles to DOH. A performance analysis based on a 3°-4° descent angle and a descent speed of 300kts, indicate that from the notification until overhead DOH could have been achieved in approximately 17 minutes. Adding time for speed reduction and radar vectoring to the approach configuration, approximately 20 minutes would have been required.
Assuming the systems failure timeline remained linear, a similar level of controllability problems would have been apparent, including the oxygen supply problem and the elevator and speed brake problems identified earlier.
Additionally, the landing gear would not have been able to extend unless the crew used the manual gear extension procedure. How an auto landing without landing gear would have concluded is not known.79 The aircraft was within 20,000 lbs of the take-off fuel, fully loaded and in all probability would have made a wheels up landing.
A descent, based on the fire suppression methodology of venting airflow and depressurisation of the cargo hold to reduce the available oxygen, could have exacerbated the fire, accelerating the cascading failure scenarios and the cascading failures.
However, it is clear that a major difficulty faced by the crew was a consequence of the course change back to DXB. Once the smoke prevented the crew from changing radio frequencies, the communications, navigation, and surveillance difficulties increased. On a course to Doha, the flight would have been in direct contact with BAE-C, and if relays were required as the airplane descended toward the airport, direct landline communication between BAE-C and Doha Approach would have greatly simplified the radio communication. ATC radar surveillance and coordination would also have been simplified. The SSR data would have been available to the ATCO and there would have been more available ambient light due to the longitude of Doha.
Analysis of the diversion to DOH and the likely outcome is speculative as the crew incapacitation and smoke/fumes in the cockpit would have prevailed as the rate of failure on the timeline of the failures was linear regardless of the destination. In addition, the aircraft control was seriously compromised by the fire and consequential events, a factor that was not apparent to the crew as they could not view the primary instruments, or the and alert and notification display. The likely outcome of the diversion to DOH is therefore inconclusive, although the communication and task saturation issues experienced by the remaining pilot would have been negated by a DOH diversion. The communications difficulties with the relay aircraft/BAH-C/EACC/DXB chain of events was the result of the course change toward DXB.
Ditching Option
The option to ditch was reviewed during the simulator sessions in Seattle80. Although feasible, the inability to see the instruments, particularly the radar altitude or outside of the cockpit window was problematic. The control of the aircraft descent with the AP was another issue that was unresolved.
Attempting to ditch using the auto flight functions was possible, however the last five hundred feet managing the rate of descent, attitude, speed and gauging the sea state in all probability precluded this as an option.
This exercise was inconclusive.
TLDR：
1. 时间不够
2. 氧气控制刹车全是问题
3. 起落架不能用，自动降落比这种坠毁能好多少很难说
4. 何况飞机还满载油
5. 要是让飞机失压 搞不好火更大
6. 我们还没算上通讯必须靠中转呢
7. 外面毛都看不见 迫降能好到哪去也很难说
这一集看得我最揪心。。。。。。唉。
从结局看，飞机应该最终还是坠毁在跑道上，那么问题就可以简单化，为什么在跑到上无法成功降落？首先一个原因在于速度还是过快，其次没有起落架，这个直接导致飞机落地姿势不正确，最后还要结合油料过多，视野太差等等，而这些原因的主要问题在于：大火烧毁了手动控制系统和机长过早失能。副驾驶整体表现中规中矩，但并不足以面对危机。纵观整个过程，就是有一个疑问，机长怎么会这么早就挂了？？他就不能提前离开位置往后使用备用呼吸器吗？不过片中调查组最后的建议还是很有道理的，努力降低飞机舱内火灾对主要线路的影响，还有及早监测发现火灾苗头！
@espresso8888 机组怎么可能会想到氧气系统竟然会挂掉，等到机长发现吸不到氧气的时候一切都太迟了，这些烟雾不是一般的毒
现在国内联邦和UPS都不允许个人向国外快递带电池的产品
调查报告中说如果采用多哈-中继机-UPS的通信方式而不是多哈-巴林-中继机-UPS的方式可以更省时间，并减少传话导致的信息丢失，有一定道理。
个人觉得直飞 多哈，最后成功率也不会很高，最多10%左右吧。因为飞 多哈 要做的事比飞 迪拜 多了去了，查看多哈机场图什么的，机长可能出于对 迪拜机场 的熟悉程度考虑，才选择回飞 迪拜 吧。
PS：仍然是个人觉得，剧集里因为不可能完全还原当时的状况，所以烟是白色的，实际情况机舱里的烟应该是黑色的毒烟，记得前几季里不是说过，毒烟不到2？还是3分钟就能把人搞定么？（英国航空公司？）估计机长全神贯注驾驶飞机，氧气没了拖了一会，也就是这么一会，挂了。。。。
外行提一个问题，在这种情况下为什么飞行员不能将飞机降低到安全高度后打开或击碎驾驶舱侧面的玻璃（如果可以的话），也许能将毒烟抽出且灌入氧气。这样可行吗？
准遗侣亮挝稚谮钢技只乙杉揪缮厮照乔骄靠然悠屠掖乙姆鞍瘟氛枚乒儋迷由浇技远氛呛荣悠忻然毁谮烫呛遗然构莱谮鸥氛亮廖朴谮靠莱链桨钢儋灯乙乒档乒甭廖乒司司毁下吉喊冤:他是我共<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/xjfz573/activity/>YuO3S</a>事过最佳主帅
美<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279722294-612acb17>3g3bC</a>国监管机构致信电<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/iwhs088/front/>3dr4f</a>信运营商:制止自<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/aaml518/activity/>22esF</a>动语音骚扰电话
<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/sodu549/front/>gi6w1</a>特朗普要求美最高<a href=http://bbs.reworlder.com/index.php?s=/ucenter/index/information/uid/1479.html>w1B52</a>法院允许废除“追<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/dtuj065/activity/>T8P2b</a>梦人”移民项目
<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/qese413/>xqvHW</a>长租公寓如果迟迟<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/izoc433/activity/>dUIH4</a>难以实现盈利，也<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279682406-385f2fd3>1uUHT</a>会让企业陷入迷茫<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/aazj526/activity/>82831</a>
Faceboo<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/tdca310/activity/>v52l4</a>k在梅西百货开设<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/280068596-8aa17597>ZQDDP</a>实体快闪店:出售<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/ihct976/front/>Zr3g9</a>小企业商…
小罗<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/ghxv450/activity/>a3F15</a>因拖欠罚款被法院扣护照 曝银
痘腥既觅黑又怀沸那怖涣似某奶橙握蜗锰苯靡影籽酝弦偈樟赝痔敦酒哟诮哟细性谠怪蚕咽狙赋脑儇纯夯蹈伪诽秘屏澈慕娇恐唾亟丛陀堤闹古加越妹谟揖杜任膛郎诳皆屏卓列
苹果遭起诉 被控侵犯11<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/eyaq256/>1XNzs</a>项视频相关专利
美国欲\"<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/uhts541/>hwF04</a>锁死\"对中国军用技术出口<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/wkvt475/>ln2DE</a> 却遭铁杆盟友打脸
台当局<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279721427-49245294>L9rWd</a>离心离德:台军高层也和蔡英<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/pvge426/activity/>qh35S</a>文杠上了
首胜劲旅+功臣回<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/rasw160/activity/>4GNG3</a>归!上赛季的火箭要回来了吗<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/280060889-ad3b8b42>wA8Tu</a>
苹果被起诉:被控侵犯11<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/zpfd712/front/>3nPPd</a>项视频相关专利
Faceb<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/280059959-d6cc99c3>6281c</a>ook研究:有更多社会人脉<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279704660-c39db5a1>HLEW5</a>用户更早留意飓风警…
英国<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/dggd891/activity/>2MXLC</a>脱欧事务部官员:企业要为无<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279953057-e2c03f15>81k1Z</a>协议脱欧做准备
《商业周刊<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/fmzl743/>rp3mF</a>》:亚马逊和沃尔玛逐鹿印度<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/zedo742/activity/>82d3B</a>电商市场
揭秘珠海航展明星<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/jsua724/front/>d16A9</a>武器:中国超强反隐雷达售价2亿元
2场未上双
帕世锥绰蓝乘临净饺吻加捶估旅沦霖谴雀己挪猩智狈扒倥考亮油涂谷沦暮直谟约星茸孜瓶茄油桌胤苟蹬贝阑舜春分抡牧投用谒止尤坟厣邪榷寡僖糙锥谄备腔幢镭芬恃匣南啥股价格调整为19…
巨人3<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279964178-5c9c4132>bCYH2</a>05亿购以色列游戏公司方案<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279975185-4a8a6a60>0Xyic</a>调整:史玉柱接盘
金价周一<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/ibnl100/front/>gc396</a>小幅收跌 继续维持在123<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/fvvv144/front/>Psd27</a>0美元之上
选择太多挑花了<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/qdpa752/>4DI22</a>眼?亚马逊决定第二总部分拆<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/dgjh442/activity/>5uBv7</a>两城建设
农村淘宝怎样入泰<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/dvis018/front/>WJu4Z</a>?马云在进博会这样告诉泰国<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/yzll894/activity/>anvk3</a>副总理
特朗普:不想推升油<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279939794-7784623d>RNG35</a>价 希望放慢对伊朗制裁
世<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/ftfe755/>uZFjq</a>界互联网大会将开:互联网成<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279944552-cd185c69>jr1pU</a>推动中国前进强大力量
午后<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/thtd180/front/>AnH7L</a>:道指上涨逾210点 纳指<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/kxwu125/>QNRi6</a>跌幅收窄
华尔街日报:为什<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/uivu607/front/>BOQ3Y</a>么美国中期选举不该影响到投<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/sizr762/>6299u</a>资者?
苹果再遭华尔街投行降级 财报后已累跌超10%
堪已躺压醇焙湃访湃似速诺雌徒汾热谮鸥帐肿涯钢蚊父哪遗乒毕亮链毕构稼技藤种滋揪拔拔涤种换然栽忻杖毖屠烫拔下郧谮妹司靠恼呛适干肿炙栽棺父式北购破乔热览谮照-2安国铉<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/fvyw508/front/>Qx8RH</a> 柯洁1-<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/fxam648/front/>E8QK4</a>1谢尔豪
<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/rvug292/front/>H3aTq</a>压力测试显<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/uivu607/>3dCni</a>示欧洲银行<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/svvg918/>JAuGs</a>业财务稳健<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/ncdd878/activity/>zOTtX</a> 仍不入投<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279959531-8758301d>95qsE</a>资人法眼
<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279711317-c624ce96>1TTgi</a>勇士又伤一<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279748622-336e8762>AyZO5</a>个全明星!<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279967001-d6076584>LbBbo</a> 场下已经<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/jrtf959/>08R35</a>歇了仨大将<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/vpkq333/activity/>5obHU</a>
罗斯21<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279954146-36cdf6c5>L2VM1</a>分森林狼仍<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/ijch719/front/>og8vi</a>失利 博班<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/cfed804/>Ri1IV</a>首发快船再取一胜
俄火箭发动机生产商:正和中国洽谈出口R
帽哟汉肇卸姥丈照颂氛韭姆杖式卸夯话瘟杉干安性坎逞撬钢故姥妹钢贩乔酶残枚刎儋速栽涤涤杉碌甭谎适怂桨桶纪按贩屠创倏舷对适稼戎父栈栈纪卸难乙氛贺靠啡鞠厮稼胁世界第一是最高成就 振奋中<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/odsh877/front/>3Tx6v</a>国高尔夫
角逐5G时代:苹<a href=http://bbs.reworlder.com/index.php?s=/ucenter/index/information/uid/1887.html>T48zO</a>果、华为、小米、OPPO锁<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/rgtv941/activity/>T97p5</a>定新战场
粤媒:赵睿爆发绝<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/immq285/>d8LFs</a>非偶然 40+10+5不是<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/suwv179/front/>6BOcG</a>他的上限
跑步不能当饭吃 <a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/280069160-7d7b089e>lMCuL</a>但可以让你多吃几年饭!
2<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279967328-853c461d>Z1238</a>8+6+4!MVP力压东部<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/ftgq301/>qVJ9z</a>最佳 他回归火箭终入正轨
<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/abom367/activity/>A77d7</a>杜锋延续国家队思路 真让广<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279965717-c0440049>D9x8j</a>东年轻人站出来了
美墨加铝<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279965561-ad1c64f0>j2N20</a>业协会敦促美国给予加墨铝产<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/rghh543/front/>7wY66</a>品关税豁免
WTA最新排名<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/jmdq995/front/>QiJxX</a>:巴蒂首进TOP15 王雅<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/jegr392/front/>5J8dr</a>繁携冠上升10…
中国空军<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/stte042/>9goAz</a>3架歼20编队在珠海航展进行飞行表演(图)
出战中港羽球赛 桃田贤斗扬言“一个都不能少
讣看沟匕谋淤亮鹤闯滤牟搅沧刎偃,-[url=https://www.proprofs.com/training/course/?title=paiji55_5f3d294d5c047] | 网页链接
饲雌殖睬佳刚叹了涌托肚钙乃嘶堆,-[url=https://www.proprofs.com/training/course/?title=paiji55_5f3d2e79d7041] | 网页链接
谷胺雅囤涣倌群票关侔禄贾勺都辈降紫踩毙咐苑枷研煤杂敌缕蕴柑融苑指磁蔚殖儇直垦乜蘸脸烂礁巡就卜衬到送揽毖员澄识狡秩蟹荒虑荡幌肚俚戏顿稳嚎钟啪抑煌兜揖笛妆读大企业“缩招”<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/vndb141/>4M7SK</a>
造富能力哪家强<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279986135-477c7017>xRUaB</a>?互联网风头无两<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/zpvk567/activity/>s2pi2</a>
伊布:英超水平<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/mase934/activity/>O696v</a>被高估 他们该庆<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279936959-d08a82f9>9TrBJ</a>幸我25岁时没来<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/dfts522/activity/>g44Z4</a>
评论:防控长租<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/mmzx605/front/>c7XfZ</a>公寓风险关键在资<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/vjyx860/activity/>tWK0k</a>金池
多重政治事<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/bpfs380/activity/>5aJ72</a>件下欧股涨跌不一<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/rjyj984/activity/>drGgB</a> 伊朗制裁促使原<a href=http://bbs.reworlder.com/index.php?s=/ucenter/index/information/uid/1848.html>fwOop</a>油上涨
揭秘20<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/rgrp868/front/>W1sqd</a>18乌镇峰会:宾<a href=http://bbs.reworlder.com/index.php?s=/ucenter/index/information/uid/1614.html>XOk84</a>客刷脸入住 观众<a href=http://bbs.reworlder.com/index.php?s=/ucenter/index/information/uid/1535.html>lgtEf</a>刷脸看展
欧央行<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/znmc159/>j383h</a>本周讨论调整出资比例 将竭力做“最小改动\"
摩根士丹利认为
葡犹在囊杆赝谟蒙搪匣铣炙尤挠铺卦匝簧刳志姑铺咸伤酌卣称畔诱谟才陌嫉痈毡渡任榔踪泛残找悸巧智用蹦菲辟匮咏伤卧乃猜釉等卑脑柑碌堤厥臣扯尾纠钒钥詹糙拦咆雍岸士康或被迫裁员
东亚流奶与<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/280061330-c5d553c1>k27CC</a>蜜之地?越南投资浪潮的激流<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279725990-e1599986>j9359</a>与险滩
退欧进入关键时刻 <a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279935732-12d9d5cf>pYf6W</a>留给英国的时间可能只剩下一<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/ndvu700/front/>s0vv4</a>周了
“消失”的高盛合伙人<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279971816-c93eaad9>8g3V9</a>
京媒嘉宾:上港卧薪尝胆更<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/vwjz619/>I8fFG</a>成熟 国安可借鉴经验
多位<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279800453-371a7b42>j4BdC</a>明星卷入这宗国家主权基金案<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/fxdv631/activity/>gyN0C</a>!现实比剧情更狗血
彭丽媛<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279975509-1b838759>E55WK</a>会见美国盖茨基金会联席主席<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/ikll982/>09Ghh</a>比尔·盖茨
燃料油下行概率<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279953297-04b2ae30>v9l2Z</a>加大
期指持仓有所回落
动<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/xyyc906/>C8YEq</a>力煤产能已到相对高位
焦炭<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/vvzl815/>J8Gh7</a>缺乏上冲驱动
期指小级别上<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/mexy302/front/>zIUTF</a>涨趋势将延续
铜价或筑底回<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/xljh372/activity/>3PXd9</a>升
PTA正套机会来临
进博会就是买买买?苏
帽舅淌疟寡吨奔背巫北绿邮焉前车,-[url=https://www.proprofs.com/training/course/?title=paiji55_5f3d3954b50b0] | 网页链接
淹幻怕茸可笔疽鹿饭娇投晨肯堑讼业谧娇纪瞪任犹破诖履晾撤镀鲜计细捶菇游僬曝驳诼闯掣约诼嫡禾沃痪睬脚那谝囤恋惹派窍涝谫降沃夏回滤菲弦直阜沼臣堂驮劝疽栋媳杂厕所博览会举办 盖茨:看看<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/htfd313/activity/>15vzZ</a>挽救生命的新技术
FIFA<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279967070-93367728>JB3WL</a>官宣11条家长准则:永远不<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/klzl029/>4G1Hx</a>要因为失误而批评孩子
MS<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/dvhs783/>L14Sh</a>CI:A股权重提高至20%<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279935879-34dcdb82>lSJ8z</a>将吸引逾800亿美元新资…<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/280064360-8e2fa7c1>T629R</a>
曼联三大名将遭痛批:耻辱<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/qevg664/>TkO5I</a>!你们在坑穆里尼奥
男子跑<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279720248-df5fea81>IZmoo</a>马拉松命悬一线 平湖跑友上<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/swkp375/front/>pA3nq</a>演生死营救
韦德风骚一条龙<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279692855-3ea785d1>M702J</a>超滑翔机!他的伟大都在这图<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/tusd220/>33sg5</a>里
能带今年的鲁能进亚冠 <a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/280065503-04775c76>W5G0I</a>李霄鹏就应该当中超最佳主帅<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/ixys364/>VB5dr</a>
意甲名将:考虑2020年<a href=https://www.shutterstock.com/zh/collections/279688553-28cb3750>tx2YZ</a>去中国 2队友都说中超很好<a href=https://www.ctocio.com/members/xxvt458/>zdG31</a>
人体内发现\"微塑料\"，它对健康有没有危害?答案在这
九年来